The Flood of Mediocrity
Open LinkedIn. Scroll through Instagram. Look at the latest corporate landing pages. Do you notice it? I notice a growing sameness: the same phrases, the same glossy images, the same tidy layouts.
AI has made "average" cheap. A technically decent logo, grammatically correct copy and a working website can now be produced with AI. That is useful. But when "good enough" is available to everyone, it stops setting anyone apart. In my view, a brand that lets AI make every decision ends up looking like every other brand that did the same.
What AI does well is recognising patterns and recombining what already exists. What it does not have is a point of view. It can predict which sentence usually comes next; it cannot decide what your company stands for, or sense what a particular audience needs to hear right now. AI can write the copy. Only a human can read the room.
That is the core of this anti-AI manifesto. It is not a rejection of AI tools: they help with research and writing, including the posts on this blog. It is a rule about who decides. A manifesto, in the sense used here, is a short set of beliefs that guides every design and content choice, from the tone of a headline to what a site deliberately leaves out.
Why does that matter? First, I think a clear stance is recognisable: in a market full of interchangeable pages, a site that takes a position is remembered. Second, I believe it filters: people who share your view feel addressed, and people who don't move on, which saves both sides time. Third, deliberate rough edges, such as an unexpected layout or an opinionated sentence, show that someone made a choice. None of this guarantees more sales, but in my view it gives a brand what AI-made sameness cannot: a reason to remember it. That is the sense in which I think human design still wins: not on speed or cost, but on being remembered.
The rest of this piece looks at why AI-made design feels off, how human and AI design differ, and how to check your own site.
Which image feels more human?
Two images, a charcoal sketch and a smooth 3D render: you pick the one that looks more like the work of a human hand and read which visible traces cause that impression.
The 'Uncanny Valley' of Web Design
You know this feeling from robotics: if a robot looks almost human but not quite, it creates a feeling of unease. I think something similar now happens with brands.
You have probably seen it: copy that opens with 'In today's digital landscape...', images with the same polished gloss. Once you notice it, I think it creates distance, and distance is the opposite of trust.
The counter-trend is an 'anti-AI' aesthetic: raw, brutalist, asymmetrical, grainy. Designs that show a human made a choice.
AI Design (The Commodity)
- Perfectly symmetrical
- Generic 'Corporate Memphis' art
- Polite, robotic copy
- Predictable layouts
Human Design (The Luxury)
- Intentional asymmetry
- Hand-drawn / Photography
- Opinionated, edgy copy
- Unexpected interactions
Why Friction is Good (Sometimes)
AI optimizes for efficiency. It wants to remove all friction. But I think friction is where memory happens.
A vinyl record has friction. You have to take it out, clean it, place the needle. It crackles. Is Spotify more efficient? Yes. Is it more memorable? For me, no.
Good web design can use 'positive friction' too: an interaction that asks for a moment of attention, an animation that surprises. The goal is not only that people click, but that they remember you.
The 'Soul' Audit
Be Unapologetically Human
At Coday, the owner plans, designs and builds your website himself. Start with what your brand stands for.


